Caiden’s Core: Character Customization

We all play games for different reasons. Some strictly for the point of PvP and killing, some for roleplaying and others for exploration and adventure. Now if we go even deeper, what do we find? I suppose I could spout some strange behavioral science out about people playing games to escape, or PvPing to prevent a superiority complex, but that would be silly! So let’s talk about character customization and how it’s changed from the good old days of Ultima Online to now, and why different people enjoy different styles of creation.

10856  360x270 ultima online character creation

Character Creation in Ultima Online

So what was available back in the day? Games like Everquest or even Lineage 2 were some of the first of their kind. Character creation wasn’t very in depth, but it was enough to prevent too many carbon copies of yourself running around. Sure you just chose your face and hair, but at the time it was more than other games where you just chose your class and your gender and appearance was already chosen for you. People were able to create for the first time avatars that they wanted other people to see themselves as in these massive online worlds. Time went on and we get games like Everquest 2, Perfect World and City of Heroes where you were introduced to…drum roll…sliders! When I first saw I could change my characters jaw, chin, eyebrows and hair color I almost made a mess in my pants. Now I’m an old school gamer that started getting into gaming during the good old days of pencil and paper RPGs like Dungeons and Dragons and some Whitewolf stuff, so this new ability to bring characters from my mind to life in a game was amazing! Surely this brought a new age of character creation to the world of online gaming. I have fond memories spending hours in games like Aion and Perfect World making my character exactly how I wanted down to the millimeter. Good times!

11969  360x270 city of heroes players

City of Heroes has some of the best character customization in any MMORPG

Well now hold on…with all these steps forward in character customization, surely this means everyone would follow in the same way. Oh how wrong I was. Let’s come to present day and look at some eagerly awaited games that were disappointing in these area. First Aika Online, as it is still decently new and has a pretty good population. What happened? This is such a solid game overall, yet they couldn’t spend a couple more months making more models for their characters? I’m one of those people that refuses to play a character of the opposite sex. It’s not because of any radical reason, I just like to immerse myself in my games and really can’t do that when I have to picture myself with big boobs and pink undies. So as fun as Aika was, I was very disappointed in its gender locked classes. The same thing goes for two games I’ve been waiting for, Vindictus and Dragon Nest. Have you seen the character creation videos of Vindictus? Holy buckets it looked like they were making actual people in that thing. I visibly grinned at the sight of this amazing development and went on to look for what classes the game has to offer. Surprise surprise, classes are gender locked. Much puppy punting ensued. I’m not sure if developers are trying to save money, or if they feel it isn’t needed, but myself and many others are put off by being forced to be male or female.

296  360x270 perfect world black elf

Perfect World has amazing customization!

Some people don’t mind not being able to make their characters the way they want. I got used to it for a while when I was in my PvP hungry phase. Screw what my character looks like, if I can kill everyone with a pulse I’m happy. Maybe not even a pulse…pulse optional! But as time went on I was spoiled by pretty games like Champions Online, Everquest 2 and Perfect World and their great character creators. All these great free MMORPG’s on the market really turn me away with their fail character creation. Yeah yeah, it isn’t a part of the game as a whole, but if I can’t look how I want in a game, it definitely ruins immersion. This is one of the reasons I left Soul of the Ultimate Nation and Ether Saga. So what about you folks? Do you look for character creation in a game as one of its make or break points, or does it not really matter?

Sorry for the article delay, busy week! Look forward to next Mondays article.

By, Caiden

caidenscorebutton

"At the Center of All Things..."

 
40 Comments
  • Isaac
    July 21, 2010
    Reply #

    character customization is always the first thing i judge on the game because im sure most dislike having clones of themselves running around

  • Ryan
    July 21, 2010
    Reply #1

    agreed..if a game is just a bunch of clones running around with the same armor and slightly different hair or face variations i don’t even touch it because i know if they didn’t try very hard, and the game itself cant be all that great. which is a curse aswell haha.

    • Phoenix9912
      July 23, 2010
      Reply #2

      In my opinion, if done right, (Like DFO, Grand Chase, etc.) it doesn’t bother you too much. But, still. Customization is an important aspect in any MMO.

    • YUUUUU
      September 11, 2010
      Reply #3

      Ironic how all those games above have the same issue with everyone wearing the same exact armor if and or around your level.

    • Heart
      February 28, 2012
      Reply #4

      can you recomend a game for me then?

  • Krevra
    July 21, 2010
    Reply #5

    For sure, Char customization is an important aspect for online gaming. I cant play games that have everyone wearing the same types of basic armor/cloths and the same look.

  • Caiden
    July 22, 2010
    Reply #6

    Thanks for the comments!

    I always enjoy a decent or preferably great character creation process. Games like Champions Online and Perfect World give you so many tools.

  • Kurpal
    July 22, 2010
    Reply #7

    I feel that character customization is a very important part of any game. The technology exists; why go lazy and not provide it? In fact, I would like to see more character creation demos released like SPORE did. It’s good advertising. Yes, I’m looking at you Champions Online. As far as I have seen, Perfect World has the best character creation in the F2P market out there.

  • Linachan
    July 22, 2010
    Reply #8

    Aika has a small pool of character builds so that the engine can support 1000 v 1000 PvP :P

  • BeamSplashX
    July 22, 2010
    Reply #9

    Fun first, then customization. Being unable to create a unique character in an MMO just seems straight-up pointless. At this point, we should be customizing the colors of our equipment and deciding how giant our giant swords will be. Games like Champions have the right idea, separating appearance from progression, while games (I think LoTRO does it) that allow characters to wear a cosmetic outfit as opposed to their equipment balances things out nicely.

    Though it’s hard to fault other developers for not living up to Perfect World (which has no height adjustment!) when other games by the company have far less customization. Refusing to live up to themselves is a pretty dire sign. Before anyone counters by saying customization is PW’s selling point against the other games, consider why we have to choose between unique gameplay and customization.

  • JDSNype
    July 22, 2010
    Reply #10

    uum may i ask why you left Ether Saga?
    That game is not gender locked, sure it is not great as Perfect World customization but better than “gender locked same face and same hair”.

  • Caiden
    July 22, 2010
    Reply #11

    Well said Beam.

    I just like being able to choose more than 5 faces and 4 hairstyles…it just makes me feel like a statistic rather than a unique character.

  • Hipparidako
    July 23, 2010
    Reply #12

    well honestly that just comes down to the whole aspect of “indivisuality”. Nobody wants people like them just running around an mmo. This is mainly beacause an mmo is (atleast virtually) an entire world we’re talking about here. In the real world if if you go somewhere and you see someone wearing EVERYTHING your waering or even have, you would most likely be annoyed at this. So naturally that kind of logic would apply to the online world.

  • Lord Quintin
    July 23, 2010
    Reply #13

    The most important thing in mmos to me is how my character looks a don”t like copies of my self all over in the world that”s why a choose games like pwi.

    • ReMo
      July 23, 2010
      Reply #14

      Unfortunately, I see doppelgangers of myself in most games =[.

      • Caiden
        July 23, 2010
        Reply #15

        Agreed. Sadly if you want quality character creation, Pay to Play is the most likely provider. However Martial Empires was a breath of fresh air.

  • mr.bojangles
    July 24, 2010
    Reply #16

    man, I think i’ll buy one of those 30 day cards for city of heroes. I miss my good old original no carbon copies character.

  • Johnny
    July 24, 2010
    Reply #17

    Man, NO ONE brings up Star Wars Galaxies. As far as I know, it was really the FIRST mmorpg to introduce sliders in character creation.

    But ultimately most people aren’t going to really pay attention to your finely crafted face, and armor and equipment are the things that stand out the most, and there’s not much variety there.

    Again, SWG was great in that aspect. Actual clothing had no stats whatsoever but still varied in price, and people still bought clothes to look good (almost like in real life) If you weren’t just starting out, chances were low that wouldn’t see anyone else with the EXACT same outfit. The only game I’ve ever played since that offered that much variety in armor obtainable in game is Mabinogi.

  • Katy
    July 24, 2010
    Reply #18

    For me, the most important thing that compels me to play a game is character customization. Like others have said, it annoys me when I see 20 other characters looking exactly the same as mine. Perfect World was definitely amazing in that aspect…I also found Grand Fantasia to be surprisingly solid in its character customization, and I haven’t seen a single clone of myself yet even though I’ve reached the higher levels.

    Then there’s games like Maple Story where the actual starting-game customization is very limited, but almost everybody gets their hands on NX Cash somehow eventually to alter their characters’ appearance and makes themselves more unique. Personality, my ideal game would be one where you don’t need to pay real-life money to create a unique character…sadly there’s not a whole lot of them out there (or maybe I just don’t know about them).

    Other than the character customization, I also place importance on the visual graphics overall and the gameplay, such as a variety of classes (not just the basic archer/warrior/mage).

    • Caiden
      July 24, 2010
      Reply #19

      Nice little read!

      And I agree with your last sentence. It’s difficult to make games completely original these days, but nice little things like classes and character creation are definitely one thing I look for new features in.

  • kikan
    July 26, 2010
    Reply #20

    Well basiclly
    I reckon if the creators of the game arnt botherd with at least giving some options at the START of the game. Then i doubt that they will have a good game waiting for you in open arms. Since they can not really be botherd with basic customisation

    • goozey
      July 26, 2010
      Reply #21

      not necessarily all games with weak character customization are going to be bad. Divine souls had bare minimum customization for their characters and it was still a solid game.

      • kikan
        July 27, 2010
        Reply #22

        Hmmm i dont really think so, i found that game quite dull, repetative and lack of anything really, dungeons were WAY to similar in all aspects.

  • Amar
    July 27, 2010
    Reply #23

    Well, if you found it to be like that, what games aren’t like that? (Not trying to sound condescending or anything, I could use a new game at this point, but I’ve played just about everything in the world of Mmo’s)

    That was directed at kikan

  • kikan
    July 28, 2010
    Reply #24

    There are plenty of games that arnt like that
    BF Bad Company
    WoW
    Splinter Cell
    Metal Gear Solid

    The list goes on…

  • Youst
    July 28, 2010
    Reply #25

    Character customization is 90 percent of what i look for in a mmorpg. I used to love eq because not only could u customize, but there were TONS of races, and items to make your char even more unique. So in my opinion having like 15 different races, male and female combined with the customization it had, puts it far above most games now. Which is sad the games over 10 years old. im sick and tired of having to scan and scan and scan. played gw, eq1 eq2 aoc warhammer lotro gw d&d aika allods all the free ones etc etc, and its gotten to the point id gladly pay for something new to have those options(d and d was okay but got sick of the late night chinese attitudes, they treat people from usa like dog poop). I never play mmorpg that has little customization. I actually came upon this article finally typing “any good mmorpgs with good character customization 2010″, on google. Im pulling my hair out trying to find something. And no i played guild wars a billion days and i hate to say it, maybe im the only one, but not interested in part 2. Specially since they always make all the weapons with the same stats. id LOVE to stay away from an asian company for awhile, but god knows nothings made in the USA anymore. Lets be honest, they put arena on the discs, but they were bought out by korea a long time ago. And besides project powder which is not an mmorpg, cash shops are crazy these days and ruin games, like allods. Theres no where to go, its all crap, all of it. They just plain lost it after the eqs wows gws etc. Im sure gw2 will be kewl, thats just me on the not interested side. I need orcs…. gnomes, like that guild “the lost sock patrol”. Those were the days….

  • Karhs
    August 4, 2010
    Reply #26

    Customization is very important to me. Almost more important than gameplay. If a game is great, but customization is bad, I won’t play. For example, there’s this game called Soul Master. I played for a few weeks, then left. Why? It wasn’t the gameplay. No, the gameplay’s awesome. You run around commanding a ton of little demon things and making them kill things. But the customization? Ugh. Right now, there is not only gender lock, but EVERYTHING lock! I want to be a priest. I don’t want to be a chick. Why are they forced together? Also, you can pick hair and eye color at the start, but the hats change hair color. My headband made my hair yellow. How!? Why can’t I remain a brown-haired bearcat? I can’t truly hate the game though. The rouge class is called bearcat. And it’s an elf type thing. Yes.

  • Icy-nee-san
    August 5, 2010
    Reply #27

    If there isn’t a good enough character creation then I’ll probably drop it unless i know a lot of people are playing it… Like Aika Online :\

    Not a fan of the sliders, but I guess theres not really a better way to go :P

  • Samuel
    August 11, 2010
    Reply #28

    ummmm… yeah… Character creation is something that every mmo should include. I mean something like Saints row(2) does, I think it allows the individual escape into a world where they can do what they want and be free about it! High Quality Character creation is an essential part to any mmo, if it wishes to be a success.

  • Josh
    August 31, 2010
    Reply #29

    Character customization has become an overwhelming obsession for me, not only in MMOs but in all games, console and PC. It’s gotten to a point where I cannot immerse myself in a game unless I can create a wide variety of character types and make moral decisions for them throughout the gameplay. I also look for deep skill progression, social or dating elements to feel as if my chatting with NPCs actually means something, and ideally, a customizable housing system.

    While some games like Mass Effect and Fable offer these elements, I would prefer the open-endedness of an MMORPG. Perfect World has great character creation. Atlantica and Runes of Magic have housing systems, and Aika is frankly my favorite in terms of gameplay and skill progression. Now, if we could get a F2P game that manages to combine these customization elements, we’d all be in virtual heaven.

  • StripedUmbrella
    October 18, 2010
    Reply #30

    Before i tell you my opinion i want you all to know i have played probably half of the games this site has listed (im not bragging because im only 15 and I spend most my time gaming with friends and my girlfriends in real life, its not that much fun with real life friends especially in pvp oriented games) but i am told im a intense gamer. and if i insult a game i will compliment it
    But i noticed i tend to like games that have Good Customization, around medium exp rating, good graphics, friendly community (4story has the most friendliest community by the way) and i would like to say that alot of games only go to one of this subjects. But if you want to call it a successful game it needs these 3. But back to graphics. I noticed that people dont like games as much if its like Vindictus (new nexon game with most unique controls system because you can use a XBOX controlelr!) but that also if it has to much customization most people just do the basics and see copies. Now World of Warcraft (just read it, i have a point) is succesful because you can level by pvp (alliance vs hord battles), quests, some repetitive quests, instances and raids, customization, alot of classes to choose from, Goals (achievements for the person that wants to have a amazing score) so if you compare games to WoW you will know why you pay for games like that compared to games like perfect world, maplestory, league of legens, champions, etc… WoW in my opinion started the gaming world. Thats all i got to say
    -Side Note for any game companies reading this-
    Dont be afraid to copy a succesful game. There is a reason a game is succesful. But dont copy every detail. but the basics, customization, classes (change some stuff to it), skill/level/job build, and the way you level in the game. I recommend to anyone that wants to get rich to copy the basics of WoW but change graphics and anything else you can think of that people dont really care about.

  • The Guru
    May 27, 2011
    Reply #31

    i dont know why people talk about WoW as a good game. i played it till i reached lvl 76 explored almost everything that my lvl would allow and i was not impressed. it seemed like it was made by some dude in his mothers basement, although i gotta say the character customization was good to an extent. If only mmo’s were well crafted and f2p along with other awsome stuff then i might actually be motivated to play longer. Games like ever quest 1&2 are good but there wayyy too huge in customizable options and it just discourages or overwhelms ppl.

  • Mous4u
    June 2, 2011
    Reply #32

    None of them are compared to APB’s Customization…. holy crap man….

  • Megz
    July 11, 2011
    Reply #33

    This is hugely important to me. And it’s not so that I can show off my avatar to the rest of the world- it’s because I am an artist. It doesn’t really bother me that much if I walk down the street and five look alikes walk by- ok it does- but not so much as usually the pre-made avatars are kind of ugly and boring. The whole population is not going to have the same taste as the dozen who created the models. Besides, I can kill something in millions of games. What I can’t do is create inside a game. A lot of times I play games as a creative outlet. And the best thing about the option to create in games is that those who’d rather spend the time kicking someone’s derriere don’t have to bother. It’s simply liberating by offering the choice.

  • Thornedrose
    July 17, 2011
    Reply #34

    For me all I care for to customize is if we can choose our height, which most don’t unfortunately.

  • GreatOne
    August 26, 2011
    Reply #35

    well i want a game with epic customisation and gameplay, i heard Aion Online has awesome customisation but the gameplay gets simple later on.
    I would love awesome customisation and a nice wide open world which is both social and filled with war (without war what else is there?)

  • BlueBunni
    November 23, 2011
    Reply #36

    My favorite part of an mmorpg is character customization! if it has deep char customization, ill be at the computer for HOURS.. not playing, but CREATING MY CHARACTER. ~_^

  • KingTyger
    December 22, 2011
    Reply #37

    I agree. Character creation has been my focus for a long time. First was armor. I wanted to look cool but not wear set pieces. I like combining(like in monster hunter). Then came the slides. That’s the first thing I check. Youtube>game name + customation. Without it I feel empty.

  • Jemcrystal
    March 3, 2012
    Reply #38

    I want great character creation plus. Why wont the game makers just ask players what they want before making a game???

  • xKaru
    March 4, 2012
    Reply #39

    I like being able to make a short, petite, innocent looking girl (with amazing tits) then Killing everyone who looks like they should be way overpowered. Its the ultimate troll because when everyone looks bad ass and you like sweet sexy and kind then you unleash the ultimate can of whoopass it stings them so much more. (btw i’m a girl irl)

Leave a Reply:




8 − = six


Recommended MMOs & MMORPGs